If you wish to have a reasonable and productive discussion, you must first affirm that you understand the following:
A. Words:
1. That words are a tool; merely a means of communicating ideas, and do not have any power or importance beyond what we give them ourselves for this purpose.
2. That a single word or phrase can have different meanings in different contexts, but can only hold one meaning at a time, and this meaning cannot be arbitrarily switched mid-discussion.
3. That different words and phrases can convey similar meanings, and the exchange of one word or phrase for another is inconsequential unless the meaning is lost.
B. Your Position:
1. That what you claim or argue is your position, and that this position is an idea, not a set of words; it can be rephrased and approached from other angles by both parties.
2. That, if you wish to change your position, you must clearly communicate that you are disbanding or laying aside your previous position, and you must convey what your new position is; you cannot change positions on the fly without notice to your discussion partner.
C. The Other Person's Position:
1. That the other person's position is only what they claim or argue, and not what you think they may be thinking; you do not get to insert words into the other person's mouth.
2. That you are to address the other person's position, and not just anything that comes to mind; you do not get to argue with another person, real or imaginary, who is not present in the discussion.
3. That, if you are told you are misunderstanding the other person's position, there is necessarily an error of communication, and you should consider the possibility that said error lies with you.
D. Argumentation:
1. That it is your responsibility to make sure your position is internally consistent.
2. That, if you contradict one of your previous statements, you must acknowledge that said previous statement is abandoned.
3. That logic, reason, and standards of evidence are universally applicable.
E. Hypotheticals:
1. That a hypothetical is a tool of discussion meant to communicate thought experiments from one person to another.
2. That a hypothetical, properly used, is unconnected to reality; no facts outside of the hypothetical effect the results of the hypothetical.
F. Other:
1. That there may be further requirements not currently stated in this document.